Support JIIS Blog Contact Us Home
The Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies
Home    News & Events   JIIS Bulletin - July 2011
News & Events
JIIS News
JIIS Events
Articles
News Database
Press Release
Newsletter
JIIS Bulletin - March 2014
JIIS Bulletin - September 2013
JIIS Bulletin-Statistical Yearbook
JIIS Bulletin - May 2013
JIIS Bulletin-Remembering Barsi
JIIS Bulletin - December 2012
JIIS Bulletin - September 2012
JIIS Bulletin - July 2012
JIIS Bulletin - May 2012
JIIS Bulletin - April 2012
JIIS Bulletin - February 2012
JIIS Bulletin - December 2011
JIIS Bulletin - September 2011
JIIS Bulletin - July 2011
JIIS Bulletin - June 2011
JIIS Bulletin - March 2011
JIIS Bulletin - January 2011
JIIS Bulletin - November 2010
JIIS Bulletin - October 2010
JIIS Bulletin - March 2014
JIIS Bulletin - July 2011
Defining water needs necessary for reconciliation
Is there enough water for everybody in this drought-blighted region to be able to broker Israeli-Palestinian agreement on that issue? It seems there is – if all parties concerned can just agree on parameters. Let's start with the basics: how does one disentangle water "needs" from water "rights," and how does one focus on that when more contentious terms like "demands" and "wants" keep popping up? The first step, says a group of Israeli and Palestinian researchers, is to clearly define "needs." But that too is a subjective exercise. 

The joint research team, led by Prof. Eran Feitelson and Dr. Abd El-Rahman Tamimi, attempted to solve this imbroglio. Serving as their starting point was conclusive evidence found in previous international studies that agreements over shared water resources are reached when the parties discuss concrete needs rather than vague principles. That helps in moulding the definition, but raises an additional aspect, "priority." In other words – reflecting the labyrinthine complexities of the Middle East – this subject too has multiple layers. 

The team made progress by identifying four types of "needs" and grouping them into two "priorities." Feitelson explains: "The top priority is the freshwater needed for a high level of human and economic development (let's call this basic domestic need). We sub-divided the second need into three priorities: the water needed for religious and cultural purposes, the minimal flows needed to sustain ecosystem requirements (environmental need) and the minimal amount of water needed for farming in places where farmers have no alternative source of livelihood (peripheral farming needs). We applied these definitions to several possible scenarios in the Israeli-Palestinian context, including a prolonging of the current situation, a possibility of 'warm' peace, and one that sees an influx of Palestinian refugees." 

The team then compared the water implications of these scenarios to the water sources available for Israelis and Palestinians combined, primarily from the shared Mountain Aquifer, taking into account the possibility of extended drought and climate change.

"Our analyses showed that the basic domestic need could be supplied in Israel and the West Bank under all scenarios, except when there is a large number of returnees. (In that case, it would be necessary to include water augmentation schemes as an integral part of any return program.)

"Under prolonged drought, however," Feitelson continues, "more water than that will be required in the very near future, say, the next decade. In contrast, the resources underneath the Gaza Strip cannot meet even the basic domestic need under any scenario. Hence, there is an urgent need for augmentation for the Gaza Strip regardless of ability to pay. The Gaza Strip needs immediate augmentation through seawater desalination in order to meet the normative basic domestic needs, even in the short run."  

The research was conducted by JIIS’ Environmental Policy Center and funded by the Peres Center for Peace and Green Cross Switzerland.
Previous Next

Jerusalem
Environmental Policy
Conflict Management
Innovation Policy
Data & Statistics
Advanced Search
© All rights reserved to The Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies Privacy Policy Consulting by InTv.co.il בניית אתרים ICS